Friday, April 06, 2007

Criminal negligence or Crying Shame ?

I have recently been on a trip to Dharamsala - known for being the seat of Tibetian government-in-exile. It is a small, beautiful hill town - where one can see the snow-covered peaks of the Dhauladhar range in the backyard. But, it suffers from a deadly disease - the one which plagues almost all our "hill-stations" - a criminal negligence towards the environment.

The biggest problem that all hill-towns suffer from is the lack of waste management. The waste of the entire city, including that of the eating-joints that constitute every second shop, is just dumped down the hill side. You are leisurely strolling on the road, admiring the beautiful sights of the distant hills, covered with a dense growth of Deodars, and then you happen to glance down the side of the mountain, and you are greeted by the ugly sight of chips and biscuit wrappers and discarded plastic bottles. We are very conscious about where we throw the empty wrappers and bottles - we carry them with us until we find a proper dustbin. But, I think, to what end ? Someome, who is in charge of cleaning that bin, will take and throw them down the hill. One day, we bought an ice-cream, and looked around for a dustbin to throw the wrapper. Seeing our dilemma on finding none, the shopkeeper took it from us and said he will dispose it off. And even before we turned about, he threw it in the small drain right in front of the shop!

Still worse is the treatment meted out to the rivers in the country where rivers are worshipped as "mother goddesses". Just before they reach the city, the rivers are so clean and pure, and from within the city, the entire drainage is channelled through the streams into the river. The amount of waste thrown in beautiful Beas, which flows right through Manali, is a crying shame. Dharamsala boasts of a stunning waterfall; to reach it one has to trek up a rocky pathway for at least 1.5 km. After your effort, you expect to be rewarded by a wonderful sight. But alongwith it, you get an eye-sore - two cold-drinks-and-snacks shops right at the foot of the fall. Even as we watched, one of the shopkeepers started washing a tubfull of dirty utensils in the pool of (which was clean an pure so far) water of the fall.

And the ongoing deforestation and construction - it is not just robbing these citites of their natural beauty, it is destroying the environmental balance. Everywhere you go, you find trees are being uprooted and the sides of the mountain are being cut to erect more and more hotels and apartment complexes. Where does that leave the beauty of the place ?

We all love to go to the hills to enjoy the weather and the view. Why cant we keep them clean and beautiful ??

10 comments:

Cuckoo said...

Well, it is the state of all the hill stations.

But when we went to Manali, we were given a jute bag by army people to keep all the plastic wastes in that & which was to be emptied on our return. Of course they charged something like Rs 25/- for that bag. I think that's a good idea.

I don't understand why in India, people everyone included, think that the boundary within they have to keep clean is restricted to their own houses. Rest all is someone else's & they can very well dirty it, spoil it.

Go to any foreign country, even the small kids don't do such things. Can you believe it, they don't even pluck flowers from the park !! they consider everything is their own & it is their responsibility to keep it in good health.

Cuckoo said...

So, do we get to see some pictures as well ?

Sigma said...

@Cuckoo: right you are - "Rest all is someone else's & they can very well dirty it, spoil it."
Pics - of course! soon to come on my travelogue :-)

Maverick said...

while we watch for the dustbins, the dustbins are never there at the right places and when we start along with our trash in the hope tht we'll throw it away when we find one, it takes forever.so in the first place the number of dustbins shd be increased to atleast let those people who really wanna throw their trash in a bin. and strict fines must be imposed on the people who don't do so. Ofcourse every country is not as small as singapore to allow for efficient management, it may take time but eventually we'll succeed if we start acting frm now. and all the NGOs concentrate on cities, some of them atleast shd start working in these places too.

Bendtherulz said...

Hi Sigma - amazing post and so close to my heart...I think I raise the hackles of most ( my companions) when I talk about not to throw this or that....believe me its so much of a pain. I am now resigned to the fact that I have to be conscious of the fact of my efforts...and may others also get even iota of same idea...for future!
I generally carry a big sack while on the road to keep the trash - this time since we hired a VAN , it was so easy to carry all our trash back to Delhi...!

@ Maverik - there are many NGO's working ( on few hills very actively) On the trek to Triund in Dharamsala - they actually encourage trekkers to pick the trash while coming down and hand over the same to these people for recycling purpose. They provide the sack for this.
Similarly - there are many eateries in Dharamsala as well as Leh which encourage you to buy water from their aquaguard system and pay only for water and keep using your old water bottle.
I agree that we need firmness and yeah fines should be imposed if required, we also need people those who can spread awareness....that would go a long way!

Sigma said...

@Maverick: You may be right, that there is a lack of dustbins. But my concern is that even when they are there, they are not properly used. I have seen people leaving all their picnic trash by the hill-sides, in the lawns of India Gate, actually just about everywhere, even when there is a dustbin just few yards away. Another one is lack of proper waste management system. Why do two stinking mountains of trash have to welcome you as you enter Delhi through the Karnal bypass??

@BTR: Thanks for your detailed response. I am glad to hear that someone (even if it just the army) is concerned, and doing something about the problem. Unfortunately I have never come across individuals or society, or even the locals who are living amidst the trash, who showed a trifle more concern than we did. What I feel is that a major part of the problem is the lack of discipline that our countrymen show in all walks of life. But I am glad that our generation (even if it just a small faction of it) is a little more aware - at least it is a beginning.

Maverick said...

i agree, people's attitude needs to be reformed much more than the number of dustbins.don't u think imposing fines will solve the matter. but imposing fines will also give way to corruption.gosh wat a vicious circle !

Sigma said...

@Maverick: No, I unfortunately have to disagree that imposing fines will reform the people - they will try to find a way out, if they cant do that they will resort to bribes, and try to follow rules when they are tired of bribing too. But the day the fines are stopped, they will reosrt to their own (dirty) selves

delhidreams said...

this is the basic hindu psyche of ignoring things until they dance on ur head...
treat her like a godess and throw in the dustbin
always disgusting

Sigma said...

@Adi: hmmmm ... dont you mean indian psyche ? ;-)